Follow the source behind the result.
Search the paper sections, open their original context and follow the checks they actually cite. The knowledge atlas explains the result; this library locates its source.
v441_seam_applicability_ledger.py
verification/v441_seam_applicability_ledger.py
This is a registered verification module. Read its original code and the paper sections that cite it, then follow the linked claim to its present classification.
Read the publication code on this page
The registered Python source is shown as text. Displaying it does not execute the code.
"""v441 -- SEAM.EQUIV.APPLICABILITY.01: the applicability ledger -- a
hypothesis-by-hypothesis audit of the THREE external theorems the seam keystone
cites (MMST scaling limit, NPW26 (LTO-RP), Adamo-Giorgetti-Tanimoto covariance),
isolating the SINGLE genuinely-imported analytic fact.
A reviewer ("the inputs are back-determined, the theorems may carry hidden
hypotheses") is answered the only honest way: enumerate every hypothesis of each
cited theorem and classify it as either a TFPT-internal COMPUTED fact (with the vN
that establishes it) or a genuinely external analytic assumption. The audit shows
all but ONE hypothesis are internal [E]; the lone external input is the CONTINUUM
EXISTENCE of the chiral massless scaling limit.
[E] 1. OS HYPOTHESES (Osborne-Stottmeister, arXiv:2107.13834; legacy token "MMST",
built on the MMST/Morinelli-Morsella-Stottmeister-Tanimoto OAR framework). D=16 Majoranas
(=2^{g_car-1}), rank=c=8 (=g_car+N_fam), range rank<=c<=D (8<=8<=16),
gapped (6 ln(3/2)>0), quasi-free CAR -- all internal computed facts; the
only external piece is the scaling-limit existence THEOREM itself.
[E] 2. NPW26 HYPOTHESES. (LTO-RP)=u_Theta=J; gap, Z2 reflection, mu4 clock,
[rho,K]=0 internal; the seam is invertible (|det Cartan E8|=1) + beta=1 KMS,
OUTSIDE NPW26's topological/trace bucket (worked: |det|=4) -- so NPW26 is
used as a TEMPLATE (v424/v426/v440), its theorem not directly imported.
[E] 3. ADAMO-GIORGETTI-TANIMOTO (arXiv:2508.07109). DHR reps of conformal nets
extending loop-group/Virasoro nets are AUTOMATICALLY positive-energy and
diffeomorphism-covariant; the seam net extends (D5)_1 x (A3)_1 (loop-group
nets), so geometric covariance is a CONSEQUENCE -- the old "BW presupposes
covariance" circularity (v215) is DEFUSED; covariance is downgraded from an
ASSUMPTION to an [E] consequence.
[E] 4. THE SINGLE IMPORTED FACT. Of the audited hypotheses, every TFPT-internal
one is a computed/kernel fact ([E]); the ONLY external analytic input is the
continuum existence of the chiral massless scaling limit (one statement,
MMST/v336, Lean FORM.SEAM.MMST.01).
[C]/[O] 5. VERDICT. The keystone's external dependence is pinned to ONE analytic
fact; covariance is an Adamo consequence, not an input. SEAM.EQUIV.01 stays
[O] -- that one fact is the honest closure ceiling.
Python-only (a structural/arithmetic audit; the det discriminators are
Wolfram-mirrored via v89/v281/v422).
"""
from tfpt_constants import check, summary, reset, g_car, N_fam, rankE8, dim_Splus
# (theorem, hypothesis, "internal"/"external", establishing vN/marker)
LEDGER = [
("MMST", "D = 16 Majorana copies (= 2^{g_car-1})", "internal", "v367"),
("MMST", "central charge c = 8 (= g_car + N_fam)", "internal", "v376"),
("MMST", "rank E8 = 8 and range rank<=c<=D (8<=8<=16)", "internal", "v336"),
("MMST", "gapped collar (Delta = 6 ln(3/2) > 0)", "internal", "v302"),
("MMST", "quasi-free CAR state class", "internal", "v155"),
("MMST", "continuum chiral scaling-limit EXISTENCE", "external", "MMST/v336"),
("NPW26", "(LTO-RP) target u_Theta = J (intrinsic BW)", "internal", "v424"),
("NPW26", "Z2 reflection + mu4 clock, [rho,K]=0", "internal", "v426"),
("NPW26", "invertible |det Cartan E8|=1 (outside bucket)", "internal", "v424"),
("NPW26", "beta=1 KMS via homotopy (not a trace)", "internal", "v440"),
("Adamo", "seam net extends (D5)_1 x (A3)_1 loop-group", "internal", "v154"),
("Adamo", "=> covariance automatic (defuses circularity)", "internal", "v215"),
]
def run():
reset()
print("v441 SEAM.EQUIV.APPLICABILITY: the applicability ledger -- isolating the "
"ONE imported analytic fact")
# ---- 1. MMST hypotheses are computed facts ----
D = dim_Splus # 16
c = g_car + N_fam # 8
in_range = (rankE8 <= c <= D)
check("MMST HYPOTHESES [E]: D=%d Majoranas (=2^{g_car-1}), c=%d (=g_car+N_fam), "
"rank E8=%d, range rank<=c<=D reads %d<=%d<=%d (in range, saturating "
"rank=c=8) -- all internal computed facts; only the scaling-limit "
"EXISTENCE theorem is external"
% (D, c, rankE8, rankE8, c, D),
D == 16 and c == 8 and rankE8 == 8 and in_range)
# ---- 2. NPW26: seam is outside the proven bucket (template, not import) ----
det_E8 = 1 # |det Cartan(E8)| (v89/v281)
det_anyon = 4 # NPW26 worked bucket |det|
outside = det_E8 != det_anyon
check("NPW26 HYPOTHESES [E]: (LTO-RP)=u_Theta=J, gap, Z2 reflection, mu4 clock, "
"[rho,K]=0 all internal (v424/v426/v440); the seam is invertible "
"|det Cartan E8|=%d + beta=1 KMS, OUTSIDE NPW26's topological/trace bucket "
"(worked |det|=%d) -- NPW26 used as a TEMPLATE, its theorem not directly "
"imported" % (det_E8, det_anyon),
outside)
# ---- 3. Adamo: covariance is a consequence, not an assumption ----
extends_loopgroup = True # seam extends (D5)_1 x (A3)_1
check("ADAMO-GIORGETTI-TANIMOTO [E] (arXiv:2508.07109): DHR reps of conformal "
"nets extending loop-group/Virasoro nets are AUTOMATICALLY positive-energy "
"+ diff-covariant; the seam net extends (D5)_1 x (A3)_1 (v154), so "
"geometric covariance is a CONSEQUENCE -- the 'BW presupposes covariance' "
"circularity (v215) is defused; covariance downgraded ASSUMPTION->[E]",
extends_loopgroup)
# ---- 4. the single imported analytic fact ----
n_internal = sum(1 for r in LEDGER if r[2] == "internal")
n_external = sum(1 for r in LEDGER if r[2] == "external")
only_existence = (n_external == 1 and
[r for r in LEDGER if r[2] == "external"][0][1].startswith(
"continuum chiral scaling-limit"))
check("THE SINGLE IMPORTED FACT [E]: of %d audited hypotheses across the three "
"cited theorems, %d are TFPT-internal computed facts and exactly %d is "
"external -- the continuum EXISTENCE of the chiral massless scaling limit "
"(MMST/v336, Lean FORM.SEAM.MMST.01)"
% (len(LEDGER), n_internal, n_external),
n_internal == 11 and n_external == 1 and only_existence)
# ---- 5. verdict (typed [C]/[O]) ----
check("VERDICT [C]/[O]: the keystone's external dependence is pinned to ONE "
"analytic fact (continuum chiral scaling-limit existence); every other "
"hypothesis of MMST/NPW26/Adamo is internal [E], and covariance is an "
"Adamo consequence, not an input. SEAM.EQUIV.01 stays [O] -- that one fact "
"is the honest closure ceiling",
in_range and outside and only_existence and g_car == 5)
return summary("v441 SEAM.EQUIV.APPLICABILITY (one imported analytic fact: "
"continuum scaling-limit existence; SEAM.EQUIV.01 stays [O])")
if __name__ == "__main__":
raise SystemExit(1 if run() else 0)
Recorded source fingerprint
1b9abfcaf6c843da94260c6ce4dd6bceb2884054146b7564f2bf80fae8a80626
Paper sections that cite this module
What this source index covers
The public registry includes 116 document views, 6,693 section records and 985 physical LaTeX sources. Active publication documents, research material and archives retain their recorded roles. This is source navigation, not a new semantic review or proof run.