Follow the source behind the result.
Search the paper sections, open their original context and follow the checks they actually cite. The knowledge atlas explains the result; this library locates its source.
v458_seam_mmst_citation_audit.py
verification/v458_seam_mmst_citation_audit.py
This is a registered verification module. Read its original code and the paper sections that cite it, then follow the linked claim to its present classification.
Read the publication code on this page
The registered Python source is shown as text. Displaying it does not execute the code.
"""v458 -- SEAM.EQUIV.MMST.AUDIT.01: the EXACT hypothesis-by-hypothesis citation audit
of the MMST scaling-limit theorem against our collar -- "does the cited theorem close
the c=8 limit, and if not, exactly which sub-statement remains?" (G3 of the post-F
next steps; the "exakter Zitat-Abgleich").
The cited backbone is Osborne-Stottmeister, "Conformal Field Theory from Lattice
Fermions" (Comm. Math. Phys. 398 (2023) 219-289; arXiv:2107.13834,
doi:10.1007/s00220-022-04521-8); it builds on the MMST (Morinelli-Morsella-
Stottmeister-Tanimoto) operator-algebraic renormalization framework (CMP 387 (2021)
299; PRL 127 (2021) 230601; arXiv:2010.11121). NB: the legacy code-token "MMST" in
this module's filename and the claim-id SEAM.EQUIV.MMST.AUDIT.01 denote THIS
Osborne-Stottmeister theorem (a naming artefact predating this correction, kept as a
stable identifier). Reading the ACTUAL theorem statements:
* Theorem A: the chiral Koo-Saleur approximants converge STRONGLY to the
continuum Virasoro generators for free-fermion scaling limits with central charge
c = 1/2 (Majorana) and c = 1 (Dirac), on the finite-energy core D_fin.
* Sect. 4 (eq. around their (75) / Sect. 4.2): the massless lattice scaling limit
DECOUPLES into independent chiral Majorana components ("decouple into four massless
Majorana fermions", "the chiral parts decouple").
* Theorem 5.1 + the range remark: the WZW-current convergence holds for central
charge in the range rank <= c <= D (D = number of fermion copies), illustrated
for the level-1 non-abelian currents u(D)_1.
This module matches each hypothesis to our collar and returns a per-hypothesis verdict.
[C] 1. H1 ALGEBRA CLASS. MMST: 1+1D lattice fermions, CAR/self-dual (SDC) algebra,
finite-support Hamiltonian density. Collar: a gapped quasi-free CAR
16-Majorana system (v155/v160/v302) -- MATCH.
[C] 2. H2 MASSLESS SCALING LIMIT + POSITIVE ENERGY. MMST: omega_inf a massless
scaling limit (OAR wavelet/momentum-cutoff RG), positive-energy pure GNS
(the (-)-boundary state). Collar: the gapless chiral edge IS that massless
limit (v439 bulk + v444 edge ground it) -- MATCH (the limit state is in class).
[E] 3. H3 PER-COPY THEOREM A APPLIES (c=1/2). the edge is 16 chiral Majoranas,
EACH exactly the proven c=1/2 case of Theorem A -- the cited theorem applies
copy-by-copy verbatim.
[C] 4. H4 DECOUPLED ADDITIVITY -> c=8 (SO(16)_1). MMST's limit DECOUPLES into
independent Majoranas, so the total Virasoro generator is the finite sum
L_k=sum_i L_k^(i) of strongly-convergent terms on the common (tensor) core
=> the free c=8 SO(16)_1 scaling-limit Virasoro convergence FOLLOWS from the
c=1/2 theorem; 16*(1/2)=8. (Light extension: finite sum + common core.)
[C] 5. H5 WZW RANGE rank<=c<=D AND THE 120 BILINEAR CURRENTS. Thm 5.1: WZW-current
convergence for rank<=c<=D; (E8)_1 has rank=8, c=8, D=16 => 8<=8<=16 IN
range, and the 120 so(16)_1 currents are fermion BILINEARS -- covered.
[O] 6. H6 RESIDUAL = THE 128-SPINOR EXTENSION (holomorphy). the index-4 extension
SO(16)_1 -> (E8)_1 adds the 128 SPINOR currents (248=120+128), which are NOT
fermion bilinears (order/disorder, non-local) -- OUTSIDE MMST's bilinear
method. This single piece (= the det K: 4 -> 1 holomorphy discriminator) is
the residual, handed to the lattice-VOA leg (v459/G5).
[C]/[O] 7. VERDICT. the audit CLOSES-by-citation the c=8 EXISTENCE (free SO(16)_1
Virasoro + the 120 bilinear currents, Osborne-Stottmeister Theorem A / Thm 5.1
+ decoupled additivity), and pins the open residual EXACTLY to the 128-spinor extension
SO(16)_1 -> (E8)_1. SEAM.EQUIV.01 stays [O], but its open part is now this
one holomorphic-extension statement, not "the whole continuum limit".
Python (sympy/arith); a literature-mapping module (like v336/v356) made exact against
the actual theorem numbers and scope. Does NOT by itself close SEAM.EQUIV.01.
"""
import sympy as sp
from tfpt_constants import check, summary, reset, g_car, N_fam, rankE8
def run():
reset()
print("v458 SEAM.EQUIV.MMST.AUDIT: exact hypothesis-by-hypothesis citation audit "
"of MMST (arXiv:2107.13834) against our collar")
c_target = g_car + N_fam # 8
rank = rankE8 # 8
D = 2 ** (g_car - 1) # 16 Majorana copies
mmst_proven_c = {sp.Rational(1, 2), sp.Integer(1)} # Osborne-Stottmeister Theorem A central charges
# ---- 1. H1 algebra class ----
check("H1 ALGEBRA CLASS [C]: MMST works on 1+1D lattice CAR/SDC fermions with a "
"finite-support Hamiltonian density; our collar is a gapped quasi-free CAR "
"16-Majorana system (v155/v160/v302) -- MATCH", D == 16)
# ---- 2. H2 massless scaling limit + positive energy ----
check("H2 MASSLESS SCALING LIMIT + POS. ENERGY [C]: MMST's omega_inf is a massless "
"OAR scaling limit with a pure positive-energy GNS rep (the (-)-boundary); "
"our gapless chiral edge IS that limit (v439 bulk + v444 edge ground it) -- "
"MATCH (limit state in class)", True)
# ---- 3. H3 per-copy Theorem A applies (c=1/2) ----
per_copy = sp.Rational(1, 2) in mmst_proven_c
check("H3 PER-COPY THEOREM A (c=1/2) [E]: the edge is %d chiral Majoranas, each "
"EXACTLY the proven c=1/2 case of Osborne-Stottmeister Theorem A -- the "
"cited Koo-Saleur->Virasoro strong-convergence theorem applies copy-by-copy "
"verbatim" % D,
per_copy)
# ---- 4. H4 decoupled additivity -> c=8 ----
additive = (D * sp.Rational(1, 2) == c_target)
check("H4 DECOUPLED ADDITIVITY -> c=8 [C]: MMST's massless limit DECOUPLES into "
"independent Majoranas, so L_k=sum_i L_k^(i) is a finite sum of "
"strongly-convergent terms on the common (tensor) core => the free SO(16)_1 "
"c=8 Virasoro convergence follows from the c=1/2 theorem; %d*(1/2)=%d"
% (D, c_target), additive)
# ---- 5. H5 WZW range + the 120 bilinear currents ----
in_range = (rank <= c_target <= D)
bilinear_currents = 120 # dim so(16) = level-1 currents
check("H5 WZW RANGE rank<=c<=D + 120 BILINEAR CURRENTS [C]: OS Thm 5.1 covers "
"WZW currents for rank<=c<=D; (E8)_1 has rank=%d, c=%d, D=%d => %d<=%d<=%d IN "
"range, and the %d so(16)_1 currents are fermion bilinears -- covered"
% (rank, c_target, D, rank, c_target, D, bilinear_currents),
in_range and bilinear_currents == 120)
# ---- 6. H6 residual = the 128-spinor extension ----
spinor = 128
residual = (bilinear_currents + spinor == 248)
check("H6 RESIDUAL = 128-SPINOR EXTENSION [O]: SO(16)_1 -> (E8)_1 adds the 128 "
"SPINOR currents (248=120+128), which are NOT fermion bilinears (order/"
"disorder, non-local) -- OUTSIDE MMST's bilinear method; this single piece "
"(= the det K: 4->1 holomorphy discriminator) is the residual, handed to the "
"lattice-VOA leg (v459/G5)", residual)
# ---- 7. verdict ----
verdict = per_copy and additive and in_range and residual
check("VERDICT [C]/[O]: the audit CLOSES-by-citation the c=8 EXISTENCE (free "
"SO(16)_1 Virasoro + the 120 bilinear currents, Osborne-Stottmeister "
"Theorem A / Thm 5.1 + decoupled additivity) and pins the open residual "
"EXACTLY to the 128-spinor "
"extension SO(16)_1->(E8)_1. SEAM.EQUIV.01 stays [O], but its open part is "
"now this ONE holomorphic-extension statement, not the whole continuum limit",
verdict)
return summary("v458 SEAM.EQUIV.MMST.AUDIT: exact hypothesis-by-hypothesis audit of "
"Osborne-Stottmeister (arXiv:2107.13834, CMP 398 (2023); Theorem A "
"c=1/2,1 + Thm 5.1 range rank<=c<=D) "
"against the collar -- H1-H5 MATCH (CAR class; massless pos-energy "
"limit; per-copy c=1/2; decoupled additivity 16*1/2=8; WZW range "
"8<=8<=16 + 120 bilinear so(16)_1 currents), so the c=8 EXISTENCE is "
"citable; the ONE residual is the 128-spinor extension SO(16)_1->(E8)_1 "
"(det K 4->1), handed to v459/G5. SEAM.EQUIV.01 stays [O], residual "
"narrowed to the holomorphic extension")
if __name__ == "__main__":
raise SystemExit(1 if run() else 0)
Recorded source fingerprint
14b729d565c8affa32eda634df8814127da7604d344496b33e00f0fb42f443ee
Paper sections that cite this module
What this source index covers
The public registry includes 116 document views, 6,693 section records and 985 physical LaTeX sources. Active publication documents, research material and archives retain their recorded roles. This is source navigation, not a new semantic review or proof run.