Conditional result
Matter readouts do not fix geometric response; original functional remains fixed
finding:matter-observations-do-not-fix-geometric-response
In the matter-only observation-class audit, geometric replica responses remain indistinguishable; the scope correction explicitly states that W→W+lambda Q[g] is therefore not automatically an admissible change to the original profile-free Gamma_grav. The original functional is fixed once the full operator, reference, domain, and continuation are fixed; its common off-shell geometric family and normalization must be derived from the source.
Scope: Applies as an identifiability limit for matter-only observations and an open bridge to the fixed original functional; it is not an alternative TFPT source or universal gravity no-go.
Required premises and original source excerpts
- P1/P2 remain declared starting axioms
This program checks which additional source, state, event, and observable structures follow from accepted TFPT principles; it does not revoke or replace P1/P2.
premise:declared-p1-p2 - Do not identify source types
Observable algebra, OS reflection, state, collar operator, time evolution, carrier connection, family holonomy, and readout are distinct data until an original map relates them.
premise:typed-source-structures - Model results remain conditional
Calculations in a fixed E8 net, quotient, family packet, or readout apply only under their stated inputs and do not select those inputs.
premise:fixed-input-models-scoped
- documents/archive--tfpt-45--source_extracts--02_carrier_source/sections/006-subsection-family-monodromy-and-occupancy.tex, lines 353–386
Source SHA256: 179b2d568e897e059c2d1ef804bb9b06ee053483d366fc9d24189f1df44253b2
bounded-excerpt · current-at-snapshot
- experiments/theory-contracts/source-observation-identifiability-20261013/PROOF.txt, lines 10–30
Source SHA256: b37b7cc9d0454954938fc348337f4da4d2d5c56f178127ad65d94df887ad672d
bounded-excerpt · current-at-snapshot
- experiments/theory-contracts/source-observation-identifiability-20261013/PROOF.txt, lines 54–55
Source SHA256: b37b7cc9d0454954938fc348337f4da4d2d5c56f178127ad65d94df887ad672d
bounded-excerpt · current-at-snapshot
- experiments/theory-contracts/seam-gravity-source-bridge-20261013/PROOF.txt, lines 145–156
Source SHA256: 9e9af4e0effd2ed218ca210eaac9edbd83656094ee4f00c5b7d392c7d6b87a5c
bounded-excerpt · current-at-snapshot