Original ledger status
REDTEAM.A.01
REDTEAM.A.01
Red Team / Stress Test Target A - adversarial attack on the (E8)_1 boundary-net identification (GATE.METRIC.03). CONFIRMS the conservative wording: central charge is NECESSARY not sufficient - (D8)_1=SO(16)_1 also has c=120/15=8 but is non-holomorphic (4 primaries 1,v,s,c), and the c=8 Narain family is positive-dimensional; (E8)_1 is the UNIQUE holomorphic c=8 net (even unimodular rank-8 lattice = E8), so HOLOMORPHY (mu-index 1) is the load-bearing extra assumption. The conformal embedding c_coset=c(E8)-c(D5)-c(A3)=8-5-3=0 is compatibility, NOT the physical subnet identification; Delta_eff>0 SUPPORTS tightness (clustering) but does not prove it; the constructive seam-Calderon->(E8)_1 map and bulk-reconstruction uniqueness are missing. VERDICT: keep 'reduced to a rigorous boundary-net identification problem', do NOT write 'metric sector closed'
Recorded status: Red-team [P] (reduced, not closed)
Dependencies, status detail and source
Canonical status: Red-team verdict: reduced, not closed [P]
Dependencies: GATE.METRIC.03; v77; v76; v61
Scripts: redteam/rt_A_e8net.py
Location: tfpt_5_redteam
Original CSV, line 151