Original ledger status
REDTEAM.F.01
REDTEAM.F.01
RED TEAM Target F -- adversarial audit of the perturbative 4D-QFT + scale round (v269-v275), published in release 5.2. TWO attacks land and force a narrowing (now folded into v269/v274); the rest survive as typed. (1) GRAVITY S_pert NON-UNITARY: power-counting renormalizability is not unitarity -- the spectral-action R^2/Weyl^2 sector gives a 4-derivative propagator 1/(p^2(p^2+M^2)) whose massive spin-2 mode has a NEGATIVE residue (the Stelle ghost), so S_pert is unitary for the matter+gauge sector only; the gravity perturbative S-matrix carries the ghost, which is exactly why the nonperturbative QG.AMB.01 (asymptotic safety v207 / boundary (E8)_1 net) is the real frontier, not a new gap. (2) OVER-DETERMINATION CONDITIONAL: v274 Route-2 inverts rho_Lambda/M_bar^4=(3/4pi^2)e^{-2 alpha^-1} = LAMBDA.BRANCH.01 [C], so the 0.11% gravity-vs-cosmology agreement is conditional on the Lambda-branch (the gravity route is unconditional). Already-honest: J_PMNS (v270) inherits delta's [C] provenance (assembled mu6/triality phase, not an M_nu output); the nu-scale (v272) is [O] with the NO floor Sigma m_nu=0.0586 eV as the one kill test. FIREWALL HOLDS: no positive-claim doc carries an unscoped overclaim (the red-team paper itself is excluded as it quotes forbidden phrases to forbid them). Verdict: SURVIVES (narrowed).
Recorded status: Red-team [P] (survives, narrowed)
Dependencies, status detail and source
Canonical status: Red-team verdict: the v269-v275 round survives as typed; two narrowings folded into v269 (gravity-sector Stelle ghost -> S_pert unitary for matter+gauge only) and v274 (over-determination conditional on the Lambda-branch). The perturbative gravity ghost IS the QG.AMB.01 frontier.
Dependencies: QFT4D.SPERT.01; QFT4D.SPERT.02; QFT4D.SPERT.03; FLAV.PMNS.03; FLAV.NUSCALE.01; SCALE.OVERDET.01; QGAMB.ROADMAP.01
Scripts: redteam/rt_F_qft4d.py
Location: tfpt_5_redteam
Original CSV, line 369